Publication Detail

Stockwell, T., R., Donath, S., Cooper-Stanbury, M., Chikritzhs, T., N., Catalano, P. and Mateo, C. (2004). Under-reporting of alcohol consumption in household surveys: a comparison of quantity-frequency, graduated-frequency and recent recall. Addiction, 99, (8), pp. 1024-1033. [RJ400]

Aim: To compare alternative survey methods for estimating a) levels of at risk alcohol consumption b) total volume of alcohol consumed per capita in comparison with estimates from sales data and investigate reasons for under-reporting.

Setting: The homes of respondents who were eligible and willing to participate.

Participants: 21,674 Australians aged 14 and older.

Design: A 2001 national household survey of drug use, experiences and attitudes with weights applied for age, sex, geographic location and day of week of interview.

Measures: Self-completion questionnaire using Quantity-Frequency and Graduated-Frequency methods plus two questions about consumption 'yesterday': one in standard drinks, another with empirically-based estimates of drink size and strength.

Results: The highest estimate of age 14+ per capita consumption of 7.00 litres of alcohol derived from recall of consumption 'yesterday' or 71% of the official estimate. When amount consumed 'yesterday' was recalled in standard drinks this estimate was 5.27 litres. Graduated-Frequency questions yielded higher estimates than did Quantity-Frequency questions both for total volume (5.25 v 4.34 litres) and also for the proportion of the population at risk of long-term alcohol-related harm (10.6% v 8.1%). With the detailed 'yesterday' method 61% of all consumption was on heavy drinking days.

Conclusions: Questions about typical quantities of alcohol consumed can lead to underestimates, as do questions about drinking 'standard drinks' of alcohol. Recent recall methods encourage fuller reporting of volumes, enable use of empirically derived estimates of alcohol content of drinks and accurate estimates of unrecorded consumption. However, they do not capture longer-term drinking patterns. It is recommended that both recent recall and measures of longer term drinking patterns are included in national surveys.

Name & Contact Details Role Research Program Location